|
REVIEWS / CRITIQUES
Approdato alla sua terza incisione discografica in dieci anni d'attività
in trio, l'altosassofonista canadese François Carrier offre in Compassion
una coraggiosa sfida intellettuale pregnate di quella spontanea musicalità
e prontezza di ricerca che ha pochi eguali nel clima distorto e gratuitamente
dissacrante di certa consolidata attualità. Il più che semplicistico
accostamento ai giorni felici di Coleman, Dolphy e Coltrane nasce spontaneo
ma è anche strettamente lagato al suono tenoristico, inquieto e talvolta
ribelle scaturito dalla forte personalità del sassofonista. Disco caratterizzato
da una natura modale e misuratamente contemplativa, il lavoro cede poco ai
compromessi rivendicando un'assoluta libertà profusa dal trio (più
l'ospite Amirault), compiutamente e con dirompente ed energica poesia.
Jazzit / Gennaio / Febbraio 2002
Gianmichele Taormina
Canadian alto sax player François Carrier has pulled together a very
talented group of musicians to transform poetry in a global context into music.
This CD bears an inescapable constancy of texture.I appreciate every approach
to the idea of the expression of Compassion on this recording, especially,
the title cut which introduces the seven remaining ventures into the improvisatory
/ compositional exploration of the CD's concept. I also appreciate the fact
that Carrier has maintained a certain integrity about the focus - he does
not become distracted.Noticeable in the first cut is its remarkable similarity
to Coltrane but on an alto: there is a slow statement of the main theme and
key changes, intense vibratos, extended arpeggiations, and a sound that comes
through the alto that is very much like a tenor would make. I see this as
taking away from the piece rather than enriching it. Lambert on drums even
makes bridges from one rhythm to another using heavy sticks on the toms and
corresponding bass thumping like Jones used to do in Coltrane's quartet; the
piano lands chords at the same time as the drums sound. This is not unlike
Tyner's chordal correspondence with Jones that lends a heavy impact to the
predominant pitches. There is a switch in timbre through the playing of the
bass and piano that continues until Carrier reintroduces the tune, which is
quite beautiful, and which he wrote.The last cut is the only one that does
not begin with the horn. There is a quick pace laid out on the snare and cymbals.
The nature of the recording is conservative. And that is perhaps the intention
of the musicians.
Jazz Review / Milwaukee, WI / May 2001
Lyn Horton
This third release from the Quebec-based Carrier trio explores the rich vein
of possibilities first tapped as hard bop came of age in the 1960s and began
to move towards a freer conception. With passionate, uncompromising musicianship,
Carrier and company probe these seams between bop structures and the avant-garde
to discover fresh improvisational terrain. Carrier's playing evokes the snaking,
vocal quality of Eric Dolphy, the idiosyncratic logic of Ornette Coleman,
and the acerbic, outward bound post-bop of Jackie McLean, in a style that
focuses on the sound, not on gratuitous, note-filled flurries. In drummer
Michel Lambert and bassist Pierre Côté, Carrier has ideal allies.
The supple, staccato rhythms of Billy Higgins, the pulse and intensity of
Elvin Jones, and the driving cymbal work of Tony Williams all find personal
expression in Lambert's committed playing. Côté, a monstrous
talent, is in audible communion with his instrument - its wood, the finish,
the strings, the flesh of his hands, and his glorious tone propelling the
others to riskier terrain, supporting them and, then, guiding them back. The
questing musical spirit evident here has roots in the high-energy and advanced
interplay of the Elvin Jones/Jimmy Garrison/Joe Farrell power trio heard on
Jones' Blue Note recordings The Ultimate and Puttin' it Together. When pianist
Steve Amirault joins in, as he does seamlessly for explorations on three tracks,
the most obvious reference point is the John Coltrane quartet of the Impulse
years, especially on the title track, which calls to mind "Spiritual"
from Live at the Village Vanguard. This is music that deserves to be heard
by anyone who enjoys the open-ended possibilities - far from exhausted - of
the '60s-era Blue Note and Impulse releases that embraced the avant-garde,
but still kept one foot planted in a more structured discipline.
Get Music / New York / April 2001
Jim Todd
Pour une fois, on ne contestera pas le choix des jurés: le Juno du
meilleur album jazz canadien revenait bel et bien à François
Carrier. À des galaxies de l'académisme pompeux de certains
nominés des années précédentes, Compassion est
un véritable coffre aux trésors. Plein de joyaux y figurent.
D'abord, le jeu de Carrier: son saxophone alto s'est carrément détaché
du mentor Phil Woods; il explore sans limites et surtout sans complexes. La
pièce-titre m'a même rappelé les longs préambules
de Pharoah Sanders, c'est bien pour dire... À l'orée d'une brillante
carrière (déjè bien amorcée), Carrier et son quatuor
acoustique cimentent des ingrédients improbables et en font une mouture
hautement digeste. Un tour de force.
VOIR Montréal / 5 avril 2001
Claude Côté
This is one of the strongest, best recorded jazz albums I've heard in a long
time. Very much in the sixties John Coltrane/Dexter Gordon tradition, due
to the soaring, probing sax lines, and equally Elvin Jones-ish in sound and
fury. Compassion, is a mature work by a mature ensemble capable of intriguing
exploration. Guest Amirault picks his spots nicely so as not to intrude on
the basic trio. Sings of greatness, here.
Musik Etc / March - April, 2001
T. Bruce Wittet
Maintenant dans l'écurie de la dynamique maison internationale Naxos,
le Trio François Carrier + 1 (l'"ajout" étant l'excellent
pianiste néo-écossais Steve Amirault) suscite facilement notre
adhésion avec cette oeuvre forte et dense, habilement amenée
par la langoureuse pièce-titre, laquelle se démarque, entre
autres, par son développement des plus naturels et plusieurs improvisations
inspirées. À souligner aussi la très grande communion
entre les musiciens: chaque matériau sonore participe au discours de
manière cohérente. Ces pièces de facture très
libre du saxophoniste François Carrier sont le fait d'un musicien et
d'un créateur de grand talent.
Paroles et Musique / Printemps 2001
Jacques Garcia
The legacy of the deeply moving and spiritual John Coltrane, who died in 1967,
is alive and well, judging by this Juno Award-winning CD by alto sax player
François Carrier. The CD was chosen Sunday as Canada's top instrumental
jazz album and Coltrane is the model in this suite of eight originals. It's
an intense musical excursion, where the search is as important as the destination.The
tunes are alternatively hard-hitting and open, varying in structure from blues
to modal, never predictable, always challenging. Carrier likes to repeat phrases
for effect, sometimes playing against the pulse for added drama. As the melodies
twist and turn, drummer Michel Lambert and bassist Pierre Côté
develop their own visions, deconstructing a line, then rebuilding. Pianist
Steve Amirault, who guests on three cuts, expands on Carrier's ideas adding
depth to this spiritual voyage
The Gazette Montreal / Thursday, March
8, 2001
Irwin Block
Belle mouture. À travers le foisonnement parfois un peu erratique du
jazz contemporain, surgissent quelques morceaux surprenants qui vous arrêtent
net et qui vous tiennent béat jusqu'à la dernière mesure.
Compassion, le troisième CD du trio François Carrier, nage précisément
dans ces eaux-là. "Trio + 1", en fait, puisque le saxophoniste
alto a convié le pianiste Steve Amirault sur trois des huit titres
de l'album. Pour le reste, l'équipage reste inchangé depuis
près de trois ans: Pierre Côté à la contrebasse
et Michel Lambert à la batterie. Pour les fans de musique improvisée,
ce seul alignement parle par lui-même. Encore faut-il ajouter que dans
le sillage de Poursuite (1994) et d'Intuition (1997), Carrier se donne littéralement
un nouveau souffle. Plus comme improvisateur que comme compositeur, cependant.
Sur ce CD marqué au premier chef par une grande liberté d'exécution,
tout est affaire de chimie, d'écoute mutuelle et d'interdépendance
tissée serrée. Le menu est varié, truffé d'emprunts
aux rythmiques africaines, aux lignes mélodiques orientales, bâti
sur un swing quasi constant qui dévie à l'occasion sur de fort
belles structures "bluesées". On y retrouve avec délice
le Pierre Côté magicien mélodiste de la contrebasse, qui
nous sert quelques-unes de ses plus belles prestations sur des pièces
comme Quest et Surrender. À la batterie, Lambert allie bien son double
rôle de père fouettard et de complice attentif dans un jeu polyrythmique
ici assez traditionnel. Quant à Amirault, ses trois participations
apportent à l'ensemble une richesse harmonique lumineuse. Du début
à la fin, le saxo de Carrier, à la fois souple et très
énergique, se déploie en toute fantaisie. Pas de moment mort.
Quelques virages négociés serrés. Du bon jazz servi de
toute évidence avec le plus grand plaisir.
Le Soleil / Le Samedi 10 Février
2001
Pierre Boulet
Eight Carrier originals showcase excellent interplay and sparkling improv,
the music ranging from sweeping soulful melodies on the opening title piece,
intensely played over busy drum salvos, to numbers that are cheerily upbeat,
even playful... (a) dramatic, taut and forcefully impressive disc"
Toronto Star / February 3, 2001
Geoff Chapman
Compassion, lumière, énergies libératrices
D'ENTRÉE de jeu, le saxophone alto de François
Carrier met la table coltranienne. Le son est costaud, hurlant, cette musique
repose sur une quête de lumière, d'énergies libératrices,
de compassion. Ces structures simples permettent une liberté maximale
à l'improvisateur-soliste. Les mesures s'enchaînent, on oublie
progressivement les comparaisons stylistiques. Car il y a là une variété
de références. Les cellules rythmiques peuvent effectivement
devenir plus latines. Puis monkiennes. Puis ces musiques se déconstruisent,
se démembrent, reprennent forme, décollent, s'envolent jusqu'au
blues pour ensuite effectuer des loopings arabisants. Le son charnu et le
le phrasé impeccable de la contrebasse (Pierre Côté) se
font remarquer. Manifestant une écoute attentive, le batteur Michel
Lambert procure à l'ensemble la pulsation nécessaire à
de très beaux emportements. Invité spécial, le pianiste
Steve Amirault s'avère encore plus mature, plus singulier. À
39 ans, François Carrier a fini par circonscrire son entière
expression. Il pourra passer le reste de son existence à la peaufiner.
La Presse / Montréal / Samedi 27
janvier 2001
Alain Brunet
Their brand-new Naxos disc Compassion offers a strong trio chemistry.
Edmonton Journal / October 27, 2000
Roger Levesque
This CD, the third from this marvelous alto player/composer, should garner
him worldwide recognition, as it's his first for a label available worldwide.
For five of the eight tracks he is heard in his usual trio setting--the unsung
Pierre Cote, a constant on all three outings, is the bassist and the highly
creative Michel Lambert the drummer. To add contrast, the world-class Steve
Amirault, the most interesting pianist currently toiling on the Montreal scene,
is the "+1" in the title. An edgy and musical effort." 9 out
of 10 rating.
Montreal Mirror / November 23, 2000
Len Dobbin
ABOUT THE MUSIC
COMPASSION.
Openness and love. A luminous melody rises like a prayer.
The soulful voice of the saxophone flows over the powerful drums and piano.
Deep inspiration and bursting intensity. An African rhythm leads to a dance
of peace. Total playing for an inventive piano solo. And return to the meditative
song flying high. Transcendent. MOKSHA. Liberation, in Sanskrit. Lively theme
and energetic swing. Unfailingly imaginative saxophone. Quick interaction
of drums and double-bass. A joyful blend. MIND AT PLAY. François used
to say: "Let's play as if we were children in a sandbox!" So here
they are for a ludic musical exploration. Playful. LO. Means "Heart and
Spirit". A slow blues with a modern harmony. Sax and piano in turns creating
a melodic line. Dissolution of the rhythm leading each instrument to an impressionistic
playing. Like touches of light. Surprising. THE STREAM. Arabist intonations
for an undulating melody. An obsessive riff on the bass. The saxophone turning
and turning to trance. Mind-blowing. QUEST. Bright theme and driving swing.
Tireless saxophone. Energetic drums soloing with mastery. Fascinating double-bass.
Can't help following them. SURRENDER. Rhythmic theme for sax and drums turning
to a blues with calls and responses. Superb melodic playing on double-bass.
Enjoyable. NYING JE. For Tibetans, that means love, tenderness, coming from
the heart, spirit, generosity, friendship, sympathy, kindness and compassion
between one and others. Swing and joy in unison. Original melodic lines on
the piano. Saxophone rising. Energetic unstoppable walking bass. Rich drums
playing. And lyrical flights of the saxophone leading to a splendid whirling.
Delightful. Born from a rare quality of presence and from respectful mutual
listening, COMPASSION is a living current. Hoping you will have as much pleasure
listening to the music of the François Carrier Trio+1 as they manifestly
had playing it.
Édith Fortier
|